Tuesday, July 6, 2010

5 Domain Modeling Tips

It's been a while since we've updated the blog. In the meantime, we've been working hard -- both consulting in the domain modeling space, as well as preparing the latest release of Graft. Given this, we're going to blog less about the technical implementation - and more about using Graft and the process of Domain Modeling.

To start we thought we'd discuss five key tips for building a domain model. We find these are generally applicable, but how and when you implement them will depend a lot on context. Key factors include the time at hand, pre-existing collateral, requirement maturity and the availability of Subject Matter Experts.

Here is a quick run down for now. We'll flesh these out over the coming weeks:

1. Draw a Real Picture
This has a lot of names - In this case it is just an informal sketch that every stakeholder will understand. Typically this is done on a white-board, but paper or online work just as well. Emphasis here isn't on building a refined model, it's about getting the landscape view, establishing an initial vocabulary and providing a basis of scope.

This picture doesn't have any formal semantics, it functions more as a conversation piece to illustrate and start grappling with the domain. Build this using whatever works for the participants. That said, if done right it can be an opportunity to gently start introducing some key modeling concepts and approaches.

2. Goal-Based Workshops
Many modeling exercises risk becoming esoteric. We encourage goal-based modeling that drives towards outcomes. Highlight the gaps, inconsistencies and pitfalls. Uncover the gnarly pieces early. You might not necessarily solve these immediately, but surfacing them is a key outcome.

Often the Goals themselves are simply driven out through workshops and consultation. In the ideal case you can derive Goals from sources such as strategic initiatives, requirements definitions, existing systems and business processes. If these aren't available or mature, focus on how the outcomes will be validated.

3. Deep-Dives, with a focus on Cohesion and Coupling
This is really where the heavy-lifting of modeling comes in. A deep-dive is a concentrated effort on an important aspect of the domain. Often the Goal-Based Workshops will help to drive out the topics.

The frequency and function of these will need to vary based upon the topic involved. Our ideal is a set of tight iterations on each topic. However, a common compromise is to run a deep-dive session, have the modeler refine the results offline and then a hold final session to reconfirm the outputs.

4. Revisit the Landscape
Deep-Dives generally uncover a lot of detail, however, before going to far down a rabbit-hole it's good to pause and check "is it really relevant?". The key question here is always "what's the context?".

Ideally you will have introduced Business Processes as a requirements driver earlier. However, if this hasn't occurred, this is a key opportunity to introduce them. The Business Process will let you ask a lot of key questions around model attributes and relationships - Are they used? When and what for? This can lead to surprising results, often for aspects the participants take for granted.

5. Iterate, Evolve & Refine
No model is ever "ultimately complete"; in fact it can be damaging to have this as a goal. It's important to plan for how a domain model can and should change over time. This can include small things - from notes and documentation on why decisions have been made and considerations for the future - through to a full roadmap on how the model needs to progress from here.

That's a very quick wrap for now. If you have any other tips, let us know and we'll see about exploring them over the coming weeks.

Jon

No comments: